‘Pull down their pants to see if they’re Muslims…’: Attack on book reading session in Ahmedabad has racist bias at roots

The attack on youths reading books at a park in Ahmedabad was the sequel to Bajrang Dal and VHP members earlier protesting the presence of books by Malala Yousafzai and Annie Frank in a school library and asking, “Why are there non-Hindu teachers in a Hindu school?”

A group of young men and women—teenagers and those in their mid-twenties—busy reading books quietly at a park in Ahmedabad in Gujarat had to undergo physical attack by men from Bajrang Dal (BD) and Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) for the very act of reading and their choice of books such as ‘I Am Malala’ and ‘The Diary of a Young Girl’.

‘I Am Malala’, by Pakistani human rights activist Malala Yousafzai, is the account of her campaign for girls’ education and rights. ‘The Diary of a Young Girl’ is Jewish girl Anne Frank’s experiences during the Nazi persecution of Jews and the Holocaust in her country, Germany.

Also read: After top publisher backs out of Sonia Gandhi’s memoirs, questions arise about political climate impacting publishing decisions

The attack on the book reading session, which took place at AUDA Garden in Ahmedabad’s Vastrapur on Thursday, August 27, has drawn criticism from across India, and pressure is rising on police in BJP-ruled Gujarat to take strict action as per law against the perpetrators.

“Check if they are Muslims by pulling down their pants,” one of the attackers was caught on camera as telling his companions during the attack on the reading session participants. Bajrang Dal members Hiren Rabari and Jimit Rabari were named in an FIR filed in connection with the incident at Vastrapur police station in Ahmedabad.

Books on display at the reading session organised by an NGO at a park in Ahmedabad.

Also WATCH: Frightening visuals from Nepal’s devastating floods: Read the story and watch the videos

Members of Bajrang Dal and VHP also allegedly used abusive language, tore many books the group was reading as they beat up the participants in the reading session. Social media is flooded with photos of injuries sustained by the participants.

There were nearly 50 young men and women reading books at the reading session organised by Students and Youth Collective Ahmedabad (SYCA), an NGO, as a protest against action by a prominent school—Anand Niketan School at Shilaj, Ahmedabad—against two books: ‘I Am Malala’ and ‘The Diary of a Young Girl’.

Also read and WATCH: Can’t one be a Muslim and take part in a Hindu festival? Actress Faria Abdullah answers hate with grace

The school had taken the two books off the library and placed the library supervisor, Munja Sams, earlier in August after both Bajrang Dal and VHP asked why the two books were in the library and staged protests at the school. These protests had taken place just days after an incident involving a tiny shard of glass found in a student’s meal at the school, leading to the student’s hospitalisation.

Ahd book reading session 3
One of the pro-Hindutva men argues with the book readers at the event in Ahmedabad on August 27.

“Why are there non-Hindu teachers in a Hindu school?” was what some of the posters carried by the protesters had on them. Other slogans included: “Knowledge of Swami Vivekananda and the Vedas — this is India’s honour”, “When will you teach the knowledge of the Vedas?”, and “Why are children being given Islamic knowledge instead of education?”

Also read: Tied up and set ablaze, Chandigarh influencer Manjeet Kaur dies after 54 days of suffering

After those protests, a show-issued a notice was issued to the school by Ahmedabad district education officer RM Chaudhary, asking it why it was forcing children to read certain types of books. The school denied the charges but dropped the two books from the library and the reading lists.

Also read: Ask The Guru: “My husband wants me to wear sarees all the time. How do I handle this?”

A spokesperson for the school told the Ahmedabad-headquartered fact-checking organisation Alt News that neither ‘I Am Malala’ nor ‘The Diary of a Young Girl’ was part of the school curriculum. Both books were removed from the school library after the protests and the show-cause notice from the DEO, she said, adding, “Apart from these two books, books by Veer Savarkar and the Dalai Lama are also available in the library. However, after the education officer issued a notice, both books have currently been removed”.

Editors' Picks

More news & views that matter
Related

17 killed, 35 injured in stampede at Durga Puja pandal in Kolkata; CM Suvendu Adhikari visits hospital

Tragedy unfolded at the popular Chore Bagan Sarbojanin Puja pandal in northern Kolkata on Saptami puja day. Failure to deal with unusual overcrowding during rain is said to be the main cause behind the stampede.

Dipke, Neha Bora detained; Opposition leaders voice support for CJP, ask if waving Tiranga is a crime

After Abhijeet Dipke and Neha Bora were detained by Delhi Police, both CJP and AISA said their whereabouts were not being made public and that they were being denied access to lawyers and associates.

Mamata Banerjee attacked with knife by woman outside home, escapes without injury

As leaders of Mamata Banerjee’s faction of Trinamool Congress targeted West Bengal’s BJP government and accused it of negligence in the security of a former CM, state industries minister Tapas Roy asked if Banerjee had forgotten the security situation during her own rule.

Delhi’s Jantar Mantar can’t be protest venue any more; CJP says ‘whole country’ will be Jantar Mantar

Delhi Police denotifies Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site and announces three alternative sites for future protests, sparking criticism from Cockroach Janta party, Congress and other Opposition parties.

Captain Smit Machchhar will be conferred with Israel’s highest bravery award for civilians

The 38-year-old Indian pilot whose heroic act inside the cockpit of a sinking plane saved the lives of 174 passengers and crew members will be honoured soon after he regains his health, Israeli President Isaac Herzog has said.

Nana Patekar dies from cardiac arrest at 75; cine world, millions of fans mourn iconic actor

"Yeh Musalman ka khoon... yeh Hindu ka khoon... Bata isme Musalman ka kaun sa, Hindu ka kaun sa." Fans recalled Nana Patekar's famous dialogue from the 1994 Bollywood movie 'Krantiveer', among others.

“I’m driven by a mission to do seva,” says PM Modi as he completes 25 years as head of govts

October 7 marks a rare milestone in Indian politics as it completes 25 years since PM Modi first took the oath of public office, beginning in 2001 as the CM of Gujarat.